Welcome to Caldwell House Restaurant
At Caldwell House Restaurant, a New American gem nestled in Lake George, NY, each meal tells a story of warmth and flavor. Renowned for its expertly cooked steaks, fresh seafood, and hearty portions, diners are welcomed with rustic charm reminiscent of a cozy log cabin. Guests rave about the rich, seasoned butter accompanying a delightful array of crackers and the beautifully presented dishes, including succulent scallops and generous cuts of prime rib. With attentive service and a lively martini bar, Caldwell House is more than a dining destination—it's an experience that invites you to savor every moment.
-
1809 US-9, Lake George, NY 12845 Hotline: (518) 668-2211
Welcome to Caldwell House Restaurant, a hidden gem nestled in the scenic surroundings of Lake George, NY. Located at 1809 US-9, this establishment serves up a delightful blend of New American cuisine that satisfies both the palate and the soul. Whether you’re celebrating a family event or simply enjoying a night out, Caldwell House promises an unforgettable dining experience.
The ambiance of Caldwell House is warm and inviting, reminiscent of a cozy log cabin. This charming setting is complemented by attentive and friendly service, making guests feel right at home. Many diners rave about the inviting atmosphere, noting how this quaint facade hides an exquisite culinary experience waiting inside.
The menu features a range of hearty and beautifully prepared dishes. Diners have praised their steak, with comments highlighting the quality and cooking perfection. Peter B. describes it as “steak cooked to perfection,” while Thomas D. mentions the “noticeable quality” of the meats at the first bite. Options like the sirloin and filet mignon come generously portioned, complete with a fresh salad, warm bread, choice of potatoes, and delicious vegetables. The scallop special is another must-try, as noted by Meri L., who received a delightful serving much larger than expected.
- Customer Favorites: Shrimp and crab cakes, prime rib, and hearty pasta dishes.
- Unique Offerings: Coca cheese spread and a cracker plate to start your meal.
- Specialty Drinks: A busy martini bar for those looking to start their evening right.
Desserts at Caldwell House are described as “over the top,” leaving diners in the highest of spirits. Douglas S. and Vegas K. also emphasize the deliciousness of every dish they tried, from appetizers to sides, suggesting that there are “no weak points” coming from the kitchen.
Reservations are recommended, as the restaurant often sees a bustling crowd eager to experience the quality and charm that Caldwell House Restaurant has to offer. Whether you’re a local or just visiting the area, make sure to include this culinary haven in your plans. With its mouth-watering menu and a commitment to excellent service, visitors often find themselves enchanted, returning time and time again.
In the words of satisfied diners, “I would return here every single time I’m in the area.” So, if you find yourself near Lake George, don’t miss your chance to savor the comforting delights of Caldwell House Restaurant.
2nd time in 5 weeks we went. Both time the food and service were amazing!!! Steak cooked to perfection. Shrimp and Crab cakes were delicious. Desserts were over the top!!
Food cooked to perfection, great service. I wish the fireplace was lit, snowy night every table full. Martini bar was also busy
Great, hearty food and warm service. Always a go-to for our family events. Will return!!
Fantastic. The quality of their meats is noticeable immediately when you take your first bite! We ordered the sirloin and the filet. They were good-sized cuts. It comes with a salad, bread, and choice of potatoes and a veggie. The service was excellent. There is a full bar! Make a reservation, the restaurant seems to always be busy.
All I can is WOW!! This place was recommended to us by our Airbnb host. After scoping Yelp, our decision was made! The food was absolutely amazing! As soon as we sat down we were given a small plate of different crackers with seasoned butter. The seasoned butter was very good. I ordered the scallop special. I was only expecting about 6-8 scallops and I was served 12! They were a decent size and full of flavor! My boyfriend ordered the prime rib and it was HUGE!! See picture! Other things that were ordered included Filet mignon and another cut it steak that I don't remember. Dinners include fresh bread, garden salad, veggie and choice of starch. Pro tip: if you chose a baked potato as your starch, put the seasoned butter on it! I went this route and it was amazing. I swapped the Caesar salad for the garden salad for a small upcharge and my boyfriend swapped us garden salad for broccoli cheddar soup. Both the salad and the soup were delicious! Everything was enjoyed by all. Our waitress was great. I would return here every single time I'm in the area. 5+ stars all the way!
The food, service and environment were fantastic, it appears as a little hole in the wall type of place from outside but inside is beautiful and the food is top notch!!!!!!!!!
I really enjoyed the experience. The food was hot and perfectly cooked. My Alfredo was not lumpy or induce Immediate heartburn like many other places I've tried. It was perfectly creamy. The scallions were a nice touch! The fried raviolis were a starter we tried from the special list. They were huge! And you got so many! The NY strip steak was huge! Lots of leftovers to go home with. The unique thing I saw here was the coke cheese spread and cracker plate you get when you get in. The restaurant has a log cabin, living room vibe. It's very warm and cozy. The service was perfect. Nikia was so nice and bubbly! I appreciated it even at the end of a shift I know it can be hard. Thank you for your attentiveness!! Highly recommend! The price is worth it!
Loved this place! Food was amazing - from the steak to the ahi tuna to the salad to the asparagus to the garlic bread to the baked potato to the mashed potato. I sampled everything from my group and there were no weak points coming from the kitchen. There is a charm to the place. I like the log cabin atmosphere, and the wait staff was top notch. I will definitely be back.